One of the frustrations of discussing Catholicism with our Protestant brothers and sisters is how easily a conversation becomes a contest of Bible verses.
A Protestant quotes one passage. A Catholic responds with another. The Protestant counters with a different interpretation, and the Catholic does the same. And so it goes.
Both sides appeal to Scripture, both believe they are defending biblical Christianity, and both remain convinced that their interpretation is correct.
But there is a more fundamental question we need to settle first: Who has the ultimate authority to determine what Scripture teaches?
This brings us to the problem with sola Scriptura.
The problem with sola Scriptura
Catholics believe Scripture is the inspired Word of God and possesses divine authority. The disagreement is whether Scripture alone is the final infallible rule of faith.
There are several serious problems with that position.
First, where does the doctrine of Scripture alone establish its own authority? The early Christian faith recognized both written and oral apostolic teaching. The idea that Christianity was meant to operate on Scripture alone, with no continuing authoritative teaching office, is not something the earliest Church understood.
Second, sola Scriptura leaves an enormous problem unanswered: Who determines the correct interpretation when sincere Christians disagree?
Protestants certainly have pastors, theologians, and confessions of faith. But none possesses the universally recognized, divinely instituted authority that Catholics believe Christ entrusted to His Church. Consequently, disagreements over doctrine can remain unresolved, with competing groups all claiming biblical support.
That is not a minor inconvenience. It is a fundamental weakness in the system.
The problem of ultimate authority
Quoting another Bible verse doesn’t necessarily resolve a disagreement. That verse must also be interpreted. Eventually, someone must have the authority to make an authentic judgment.
This is where the Catholic understanding differs. Christ established a Church and entrusted His apostles with the authority to teach and govern. The Church was never intended to be merely an association of believers, each independently interpreting the faith and deciding for himself what is true.
The Catholic Church does not claim that the Magisterium stands above Scripture. Rather, the Magisterium serves the Word of God, faithfully guarding and interpreting the deposit of faith entrusted to the Church.
What about the Bible itself?
There is another difficulty with sola Scriptura. The Bible does not contain its own inspired table of contents.
How do we know which books belong in Scripture and which do not? We recognize the canon through the historical witness and discernment of the Church, guided by the Holy Spirit.
The Church did not make these books inspired, but she authoritatively recognized the books that belong to Sacred Scripture.
It is rather ironic to rely upon the Church’s historical judgment to establish the contents of the Bible while denying that the Church possesses any comparable authority to authentically interpret the faith.
The real issue
I have no objection to discussing Scripture. Catholics should know it, read it, and defend the faith.
But endless verse-slinging accomplishes very little when the more fundamental question of authority remains unanswered.
The problem with sola Scriptura is that it creates a system in which Scripture is declared the final authority, yet there is no universally recognized authority to settle disputes over its meaning. It overlooks the role of apostolic Tradition and leaves the Church without the teaching authority Christ intended her to exercise.
Christianity was never intended to be a collection of individuals independently determining the meaning of God’s Word.
Christ established a Church, entrusted it with preserving and teaching the faith, and promised the guidance of the Holy Spirit.
Catholicism is not Scripture versus the Church. It is Scripture, apostolic Tradition, and the teaching authority of the Church working together to preserve the one deposit of faith.
And perhaps this is where the real difficulty lies.
Christians have no problem believing that Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit, born of a virgin, performed miracles that defied the natural order, died, and rose bodily from the dead. These are extraordinary claims that require extraordinary faith.
Yet, for some Christians, believing that this same Christ established a Church that would be protected by the Holy Spirit from teaching error in matters of faith and morals is somehow a bridge too far.
Think about that.
We believe Christ can conquer death, but struggle to believe He can preserve His own Church from doctrinal error.
Perhaps before exchanging another dozen Bible verses, we should answer the more important question:
Did Jesus Christ establish a Church with the authority and divine protection necessary to preserve and teach His truth?
That is where the discussion needs to begin